Monday, May 22, 2006

Is it an "Abortion" Bill?

From The Star:

OTTAWA--A Conservative MP has introduced a private member's bill that would make it a separate criminal offence to harm an unborn child in cases where a pregnant mother is assaulted or murdered.

The bill that pro-choice advocates say has implications for the abortion debate in this country "is not an abortion bill," says Alberta Conservative backbencher Leon Benoit, who describes himself as "pro-life."

I am skeptical of Mr. Benoit's claim, especially as in the U.S. Pro-Lifers have been attempting for years to employ Fetal Homicide billsas part of their quest to overturn Roe vs. Wade, the idea being that if you are willing to recognize that a fetus is a separate person with their own set of rights, it follows that abortion is murder. Something similar is surely going on in this case.

Despite Harper's promise to not "initiate" any abortion legislation during his first mandate, he always left open the possibility a private member's bill, and those of us who spoke of a Tory Hidden Agenda predicted something that like this would take place. While I suppose we are safe enough in a minority government situation, give Harper a majority and watch out.

Incidentally, I think that Harper's using a "free vote" to settle such issues is entirely disingenuous, as it allows him to (perhaps) legislate restrictions through private members initiatives and at the end of the day say "Oh Look! We've banned abortion, but its not my fault! Its just democracy at work! The Will of Parliament!" and other such nonsense.

4 comments:

Ti-Guy said...

It's attempting to define the fetus as a separate person with its own rights. Regardless of what one personally believes about that, it's a definition that has no legal validity.

This bill is idiotic.

Anonymous said...

sort of like the four previous private member's bills introduced over the last few years. The same thing will happen . . . nothing, won't go anywhere.

And oh ya, the previous four anti-abortion bills were all introduced by Liberals.

That secret agenda just keeps lealing ouy

Robert McClelland said...

And oh ya, the previous four anti-abortion bills were all introduced by Liberals.

Nice try. Do you right whingers even know how to tell the truth anymore?

HearHere said...

Aimilar bill in Alberta awarded insurance claim damages to a child that was severely injured in a car accident while in the womb.

The "unborn" were not covered by insurance for the injuries sustained. The bill that passed in Alberta was very restrictive but did allow damages to be awarded to this child.